The Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship

Close this search box.

Attributes of an interoperable annotation

Summarizes results of discussions on interoperability from the Kick off Meeting.

(The following adapted from the meeting summary by Brooks Hanson):

An interoperable annotation layer should enable organized, connected, curated, enrichment layers for all curated online content that allows:

  • Open but standard framework that allows/supports/enables enrichment by community and global discovery to the extent possible.
  • Granular annotations for online elements (html text, images, data, PDF, epub, etc.)
  • Discovery and linking of annotations across different content instances (html vs. pdf)
  • Public, private, group, private group, and authoritative or branded conversations and ability to evolve permissions on selected annotations
  • Selection by both content creators and users
  • Common identification of private conversations
  • Follow/notification
  • Classifications and endorsements, including authoritative endorsement
  • Identities and management of identities among systems
  • Discovery and linking of annotations across multiple versions of content—for scholarly research across multiple repositories, preprints, etc.
  • Persistence as content changes/evolves to new versions.
  • Support for the notion of the “clean page”, letting readers choose which annotations to layer in.
  • Standard identifiers and metadata that allow sharing, discovery, and connections across multiple repositories and implementations and organizing annotations for specified uses
  • People identifiers within groups and globally (SSO including with ORCID), w/ Twitter, other SM groups
  • Tags that help filter, sort, identify annotations by date, relevance, topic…factual annotations vs. comments  (pragmatic vs. true semantic interoperability)
  • Consistently identified regardless of where created
  • Many different clients that support basic functionality
  • Rich connections to other online resources
  • Portability across hosting services
  • Automatic linking of other resources and discussions (e.g., Altmetrics/Mendeley/ResearchGate/F1000/PubPeer/git/Trellis)?
  • Fully accessible (508 compliant)
  • Further mining and analysis
  • Automated/programmatic annotations/tagging/reference annotations



Maryann Martone

Maryann Martone

Current Groups


Join the FORCE11 community and take part in our groups, conference, summer school, post on force, and attend other events.