The Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship

Secretive and Subjective, Peer Review Proves Resistant to Study

Author: Jennifer Couzin-Frankel

while many pieces of the publications puzzle are yielding to scrutiny, the peer-review process itself is not. "Nothing much has changed in 25 years," says Ana Marušić of the University of Split in Croatia, who studies research methodologies. "It's always the same story." Interventions to improve peer review fail again and again. Mentorship to train reviewers doesn't make a difference in their ability to spot problems in papers. And there is still scant evidence that peer review makes published papers any stronger.

Journal: Science Magazine 2013

Archive: https://archive.force11.net/node/6380

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

Membership

Join the FORCE11 community and take part in our groups, conference, summer school, post on FORCE11, and attend other events.

Membership

FORCE2022 Sponsors

The FORCE11 community thanks the following organizations for their financial support of the
FORCE2022 annual conference.